Where To Stay In Florence: A Guide for First Timers

Santa Croce: Our #1 Recommendation (Where We’ve Stayed)

Santa Croce, which is where we like to stay in Florence, is just east of the Duomo (so slightly outside of the busiest part of central Florence) and offers a nice combination of walkability and places to eat and drink. 

The neighborhood is centered around Piazza di Santa Croce and the Basilica di Santa Croce di Firenze with its multi-colored facade, and stretches south to the Arno River and north up to Mercato Sant’Ambrogio. Generally speaking, the further east you go in Santa Croce, the fewer tourists you’ll see. 

There are a few reasons we like this part of Florence. 

One, we’re big walkers (we often get 25,000 or 30,000 steps in a day when we’re traveling) and from here, you’ll be able to walk basically everywhere in Florence (though the train station is a longer walk).

It’s 5-10 minutes to the Duomo and Piazza della Signoria, and just a little longer to the Arno River and the many bridges crossing it. 

Two, there are tons of good places to eat and drink in this part of the city (particularly for gluten free travelers – here’s our guide to eating gluten free in Florence).

Mercato Sant’Ambrogio is a good choice if you want to sample a bunch of different things, and a few of our favorite coffee shops in Florence are within this neighborhood’s rough boundaries. 

Pros and Cons of Staying in Santa Croce

Here are the pros and cons of staying in Santa Croce as we see them.

Pros of Staying in Santa Croce

• It’s (slightly) less crowded. Being just outside of the historic center, you can expect to find fewer tourists around. However, it’s worth remembering that it is still the center of Florence, so there are absolutely still tourists. It’s just that there are going to be fewer of the wall-to-wall streets packed with tourists just there for the day. 
  
  
• It’s in a central location. Santa Croce is only a 5-10 minute walk to many of the main landmarks of the city center, including Piazza della Signoria (and the Uffizi Gallery) and the Duomo.
  
  
• It has a great nightlife scene. Santa Croce is well-known for its vibrant nightlife, and is particularly popular with the city’s student population. Heading out for some drinks here is a must, and the party is often still going into the early morning hours (which you’ll also find below in the cons section). 
  
  
• It’s basically heaven for foodies. Mercato Sant’Ambrogio and the area surrounding it is the place to go for some of the best affordable local restaurants and cafes in Florence.

Cons of Staying in Santa Croce

• It can be noisy at night. With its many restaurants, late-night bars, and live music venues, the area can remain noisy late into the evening and night. We experienced this when we stayed here and walked back to our apartment around midnight only to find the streets PACKED with young people out drinking (and the related carnage walking the same route the next morning). 

The Best Places to Stay in Santa Croce

There are a couple of places to stay in Santa Croce that we think you’ll like.

Pietrapiana Boutique Apartments (Where We’ve Stayed)

First of all, we stayed here, and highly recommend it for both the location and the apartments themselves. 

We generally opt for apartments over hotels when we’re traveling because I have Celiac Disease and like to have access to a kitchen.

Pietrapiana was once an old family home in the ​​Sant’Ambrogio district that has since been converted into 12 boutique apartments by a group of friends from Florence. All of the apartments are decorated in minimalist style with white walls and simple wood furnishings. 

This would be a great place for groups and families to stay, because they have apartments with multiple beds that will make it so you can all stay together in the same unit, versus having to book separate hotel rooms (which, as you probably know, can get pricey). 

They have options ranging from hotel-style rooms without kitchens to studios, one bedroom apartments, and two bedroom apartments that sleep up to five people. 

The kitchen in our one bedroom unit was small, but plenty for what we needed with a fridge, sink, and two-burner stovetop with all the dishes and cookware you might need. 

One of the benefits here is that you can leave your luggage before or after checking in or out, which is an amenity that most apartments don’t have. 

We highly recommend it if you’re looking for a nice, comfortable apartment in a central location (that is also pretty quiet, because the units are set back from the street). 

Dimora 72: A Great Value in Santa Croce

This small B&B – which is a couple of blocks north of the Basilica di Santa Croce – only has a few units (four), so book early if this is where you want to stay.

The nature of having just four units means you’re also going to get more personalized service from the hosts (something that numerous reviews called out, which is why we mention it). 

The units here have been recently renovated, and offer a range of room types from typical hotel-style rooms with double beds (worth noting that it’s a very spacious room compared to many you’ll find in Florence) to a suite with a full kitchen (there’s only one of these). 

Clean, modern design elements are the name of the game here, with white walls and stylish bathrooms. 

It’s an old building, but the units have air conditioning, which is crucial in the sweltering summer months in central Italy. 

The location is great, the rooms are comfortable, and the staff is friendly and helpful. Not sure what else you could want in a home base for exploring the city!

The Centro Storico: The Best Location for First Timers

Florence’s historic center is the heart of the city, with the massive dome of Florence’s Duomo – Cattedrale di Santa Maria del Fiore – serving as the functional and architectural centerpoint. 

For the purposes of this guide, we’re consolidating everything from San Lorenzo, which is at the northwestern edge of the neighborhood near the train station, down past the Duomo to the Arno River and Piazza della Signoria.

It’s a relatively big area with pockets that look and feel slightly different, but at the end of the day will all offer a relatively similar experience for visitors to Florence. 

And that experience is one that certainly has pros and cons, which we’ll get to in a second, and might not be for everyone. 

The main benefit of staying here is full immersion in the opulence of Florence. The architecture is gorgeous, and we still marvel at Brunneleschi’s Dome every time we lay eyes on it. 

However, the use of the word “opulence” might tip you off to one of the trade offs of this area – it’s the most expensive part of Florence. Which makes sense, because it’s as central as it gets.

There are lots of choices when it comes to hotels here – including some with Duomo views – but you’re going to pay for it. 

The other thing to know is that, while Florence and the rest of Tuscany offer a top tier food culture, featuring things like the famous Florentine steaks to wild boar ragu that my mom fell in love with on our Tuscany road trip for her 60th birthday.  

However, the historic center is probably not the best place to experience that food culture (though there are some gems, like the highly recommended Trattoria Mario – go for lunch!), because many of the restaurants here have pictures on their menu (something to avoid at almost all costs) and are catered exclusively to tourists. Plan on doing your research and eating some of your meals elsewhere!

Pros and Cons of Staying in the Centro Storico

Here are the pros and cons of staying in the heart of Florence’s Centro Storico as we see them.

Pros of Staying in the Centro Storico

• Close to all the attractions. No matter where you stay in the Centro Storico, you’re guaranteed to be just a few minutes walk to all of the city’s main sites.
  
  
• Tons of hotels to choose from. It’s not surprising, but this part of the city has the largest concentration of hotels of any neighborhood, which means a nice range of hotels to choose from (though, as we’ll get to, they do skew slightly pricier than elsewhere in the city). 

Cons of Staying in the Centro Storico

• Lots of tourists. Staying in the heart of Florence’s Centro Storico does mean you’ll likely be surrounded by other tourists most of the time. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing if you don’t mind the crowds and are not looking for a more ‘local’ experience (to the extent that that even exists for travelers in Florence).
  
  
• Higher prices. Due to the high demand in this area, it can be one of the more expensive places to stay in Florence. There are a lot of options, but not as many on the budget side of the spectrum as we’d like. 
  
  
• No parking. If you’re visiting Florence as part of an Italian road trip, it’s important to remember that the city’s historic center is a limited traffic zone (ZTL) so you won’t be able to drive or park here.

The Best Places to Stay in the Centro Storico

There are a couple of places to stay in Florence’s historic center that we think you’ll like.

Relais Piazza Signoria: Spacious Apartments (Good for Groups & Families)

As the name suggests, Relais Piazza Signoria is located in a renovated historic building right on Piazza Signoria, one of the most important squares in Florence (where you’ll find Palazzo Vecchio, the replica statue of David, and the statue of Cosimo I de’ Medici, who shaped the city as you see it today). 

From here, you can reach the Uffizi Gallery and Duomo (not to mention Ponte Vecchio and Oltrarno) in mere minutes. You really can’t get any more centrally located than this.

Rooms range from studio apartments with unbeatable views across the piazza to a stunning and spacious penthouse with its own private terrace. 

Each room also comes with its own fully equipped kitchenette, which we value because we often like to cook for ourselves (especially breakfast) to save money when we’re on the road. 

The Artists’ Palace Florence: A Great Value in a Convenient Location

This recently renovated boutique hotel is right on Piazza di San Lorenzo, and many of the rooms have views of the stone facade of the Basilica di San Lorenzo. 

The location here is pretty nice because, on the one hand, it’s the closest part of the historic center to the train station (7-10 minutes on foot), which means a relatively easy journey on arrival and departure. 

On the other hand, it’s also just one long block from the Duomo (and the area around San Lorenzo is actually a great place to eat, despite its location smack dab in the middle of a tourist-centric area). 

The building itself dates back to the 1500s, though it has been beautifully renovated on the inside to bring it into the 21st Century, with modern, minimalist design, lots of natural light, and carefully thought-out amenities like air conditioning (a necessity if you’re visiting Florence during the summer). 

Rooms range in size and layout from classic hotel-style rooms to family rooms (multiple beds in a larger space) and deluxe family rooms (two connected rooms). 

Room Mate Isabella: A Beautiful Boutique Hotel + Great Location

The first of two Room Mate hotels on this list (a hotel brand we like, though we haven’t stayed with them yet), this location of Room Mate Isabella is truly excellent. 

It’s about a five to seven minute walk to the west of Piazza della Signoria (and the Uffizi Gallery), and another five or so minutes to Piazza del Duomo.

It’s also directly across the river from Piazza Santo Spirito, which you should definitely visit while you’re in town. 

Taking a step back, Room Mate has two types of hotels in their portfolios: the more youthful (and affordable) Room Mate brand, and the “Room Mate Collection” brand, which trends more towards the luxury or boutique hotel monicker. 

This hotel is under the “Collection” umbrella, and the decor feels very elegant and ornate. 

Rooms here are a blend of contemporary and traditional, with bold colors mixed with exposed wood beam ceilings. 

In terms of configurations, there’s nothing particularly noteworthy here – they have your usual hotel room configurations, some with a bit more space (including their Junior Suites, which are the biggest version), some more compact with just a bed and a chair.

Oltrarno: A More Residential Option Across the River

If you asked us to pack up and move to Florence tomorrow and choose a neighborhood from the ones in this guide to live in, we’d choose Oltrarno.

The name roughly translates to “across the Arno,” and it sits on the south side of the river, opposite from the historic center (though, crucially, just a short walk away). 

However, it’s almost always the case that the neighborhoods we’d want to live in are the ones that don’t have as many options in terms of accommodations for tourists, which is certainly the case here (and is part of the reason why it stands out to us). 

The energy around Piazza Santo Spirito in the evening is reminiscent of parts of Rome’s Trastevere, which is our favorite place to stay in Rome.

People sitting around the piazza, either at one of the terraces or on the benches around the fountain, and just being with each other. 

The buzz of animated conversation can be heard from blocks in any direction at times (mostly weekend evenings), and we appreciate the energy, which is something you don’t get all that often at home (do we even have shared public spaces anymore?). 

Aside from that single piazza, there are plenty of other things to do, see, eat, and drink in Oltrarno that make it worth your time, including our personal favorite gelato shops and wine bars in the city. 

The other thing we like about this part of the city is the green spaces, which is something we’re spoiled with at home in Portland (and is a big reason why we’ve fallen in love with our adopted home city). 

Between the Boboli Gardens and the small-but-mighty Giardino Bardini (which you should walk through on your way up to Piazzale Michelangelo, the best view in Florence), there are a plethora of green spaces to enjoy (which can’t be said for the other side of the river, where it’s all concrete or stone all the time for the most part). 

Pros and Cons of Staying in Oltrarno

Here are the pros and cons of staying in Oltrarno as we see them.

Pros of Staying in Oltrarno

• It’s less crowded. The big tourist crowds of the city center tend not to make it down to Oltrano, making it better for quiet stays.
  
  
• Great nightlife. The piazzas of Santo Spirito and San Frediano are packed with cool bars which are popular with the city’s young local crowd.
  
  
• Parking. Some parts of Oltrarno are outside of the ZTL so it’s a convenient place to stay if you’re traveling by car.

Cons of Staying in Oltrarno

• Not many places to stay. The biggest problem with Oltrarno as a home base is that there just aren’t that many places to stay here. 
  
  
• Distance from main attractions. Parts of Oltrano are a little further away from the city’s main attractions north of the river so you’ll either need to walk further or make the most of Florence’s fleet of small electric ATAF buses.

The Best Places to Stay in Oltrarno

There are a couple of places to stay in Oltrarno that we think you’ll like.

FuordArno Bed & Breakfast: A Charming B&B on the Arno River

We do love a good bed and breakfast – and that does mean that both the bed and the breakfast have to be included.

This charming B&B is just up the road from the main stretch in Oltrarno, and is a slightly more budget-friendly option on the eastern end of the neighborhood, close to Porta San Niccolò. 

It’s located in an old family home and has just five rooms to choose from, sleeping between two and four people. Which means it’s a relatively small place, so book early!

Each room is named after a different city/place around the world and is beautifully decorated to match the city’s vibe, such as the colorful Bali room with a curtained four poster bed, or the chic Copenhagen room with a simple Nordic aesthetic.

There’s also a cozy lounge for guests to use, with a TV, games, magazines, and books, as well as a communal kitchen where a complimentary breakfast is prepared each morning.

Bob W Ponte Vecchio: A Nice Aparthotel in an Unbeatable Location

Bob W is a brand of aparthotels – which has quickly become our favorite genre of places to stay over the course of our extensive travels these past few years – and they have been expanding across Europe rapidly recently. 

An aparthotel basically combines the convenience of a hotel – with a front desk and onsite staff – with the space and access to a kitchen that you get when you book a vacation rental.

For us, it’s the best of both worlds, especially considering Matt has Celiac Disease and having access to a kitchen makes travel easier. 

The location of Bob W Ponte Vecchio is right in the heart of all the action, a few blocks off of the south end of famous Ponte Vecchio along one of the main drags in Oltrarno.

It’s also within a block or two of one of our favorite coffee shops in Florence, Alysha’s favorite gelato in Florence, and our favorite wine bar. 

In addition to that stuff in Oltrarno, you’ll also be walking distance to everything in the historic center, but in a slightly quieter location on the other side of the river. 

This particular aparthotel has a mix of studio and one bedroom options (no bigger options for groups and families), but even the studios are extremely spacious at just under 500 square feet, which is roughly double – if not more – the size of your average hotel room in Italy. 

Some of the units have a nice little outdoor space (either a balcony or a terrace) and all units have kitchen facilities. 

Overall, a good option if you want to stay in a place where people actually live, and want the extra space that an apartment gives you without the downsides of a vacation rental. 

Casa Botticelli: A Nice Boutique Hotel in a Quiet Location

This boutique hotel is up the hill near Palazzo Pitti and the Boboli Gardens, which puts you a short walk away – less than five minutes – to Piazza Santo Spirito and the heart of the neighborhood. 

They basically have two room types to choose from – their superior rooms (which are far less exciting from a design perspective, we think), and their deluxe rooms, which feature bold colors, ornate touches like painted ceilings, and a bathtub in the living room (if that’s your style). 

In terms of amenities, this hotel has a bunch of nice add-ons, including breakfast included in the price of your room and free coffee, tea, and snacks. 

Horto Convento: A Unique Stay in a Former Monastery (with Easy Parking!)

One of the first things we want to say about Horto Convento, a beautiful modern hotel located inside a former monastery from the 12th Century, is that they are outside of Florence’s ZTL (Zona Traffico Limitato), which is a huge plus if you’re arriving in Florence with a rental car. 

Basically, you aren’t allowed to drive in the historic center without a permit otherwise you will get a large ticket mailed to you in somewhere between two and 36 months.

Being outside the ZTL means you don’t have to deal with that (which we’ve done before and don’t recommend).

You might think that being outside of the ZTL means you’re going to be too far out to be walkable to the main sights, but that’s not the case here.

You’re a seven (ish) minute walk west of Piazza Santo Spirito, which means that you’re about 20 minutes on foot to Piazza della Signoria (and the Uffizi Gallery). 

They have a bunch of variations of hotel-style rooms, most with one king bed (and an option to split it into two twins) and various configurations of seating areas.

Rooms are minimalist, with clean designs featuring lots of white and small touches of luxury like fluffy slippers and bathrobes. 

Breakfast here is included in the room rate, and it’s a pretty standard breakfast from an Italian hotel, with pastries, cold cuts, cheese, fruit, and, of course, coffee. 

Ad Astra Suites: A Nice B&B in a Quieter Location

Removed from the hustle and bustle of the heart of Oltrarno, AdAstra Suites is on a garden southwest of Santo Spirito, which means it IS a longer walk to basically everything on your Florence itinerary, but it also means that you’re in a much more relaxing atmosphere that almost feels like you’re not in one of the most heavily visited cities in the world. 

The hotel is in a renovated mansion that has a gorgeous wrap around terrace, which overlooks the gardens and is where breakfast is served (it’s included in the room rate).  

There are only 16 rooms here, and they come in a variety of configurations (though they’re all individually decorated, so no two rooms are exactly alike).

There are four rooms that open straight out onto the terrace, and the “King View” rooms have EXCELLENT views out onto the gardens.

San Marco: The Best Value in Florence (+ It’s Quieter!)

If you’re looking for a more affordable place to stay that is walkable to the historic center but doesn’t have as much going on as the other neighborhoods in this guide, San Marco is probably a good bet. 

Staying here means paying 10-20% less for a room, but adding a 10-15 minute walk to your journey to most of Florence’s main sights (with the notable exception of the Galleria dell’Accademia di Firenze). 

The other benefit of staying here is that, because there’s not much to do or see here in terms of traditional tourist attractions, it’s going to be significantly quieter and less crowded than the other parts of Florence you’re going to venture out into.

An oasis of relative calm in a city that is nearly pure chaos during peak season. 

If you value a good night’s sleep (we do!), you’ll be more likely to get it here than in, say, Santa Croce, where the nightlife extends into the early morning hours on Fridays and Saturdays. 

Overall, San Marco is a good option if you’re on a budget and don’t mind a little extra travel time to get from place to place, but the neighborhood itself doesn’t offer much in terms of attractions. 

Pros and Cons of Staying in San Marco

Here are the pros and cons of staying in San Marco as we see them.

Pros of Staying in San Marco 

• It’s more affordable. The combination of a plethora of hotels and being a bit outside of the traditional tourist areas means that the prices are going to be a bit more affordable in this part of Florence.
  
  
• It’s relatively walkable to the center. From most of our hotel suggestions below, it’s a 10-15 minute walk to the Duomo (further to cross the river into Oltrarno or over to Santa Croce).
  
  
• Lots of hotels to choose from. There are plenty of hotel options here with a range of budget-friendly options, which can’t be said for the more central parts of the city. Most of the hotels here are further north near Piazza della Libertà, which has tradeoffs – it’s further from the center, but closer to the bus lines that circumnavigate the historic center to take you to Sant’Ambrogio, Piazzale Michelangelo, and Oltrarno (it takes ~30 minutes, but it’s faster than walking). 
  
  
• It’s quieter. The lack of traditional tourist attractions in the main part of the neighborhood and the relative distance from the center means it’s not the nightlife hub that Santa Croce is. It’ll be a bit quieter and more low-key than staying more central. 

Cons of Staying in San Marco

• The neighborhood itself is a little dull. Especially the further north and west you go, away from the center and the University. But that’s not a huge issue because you’re close enough to the other more exciting parts of the city. 
  
  
• It’s far from Oltrarno and the other side of the river. Places like Pitti Palace, Piazzale Michelangelo, and the Boboli Gardens are a ~40 minute walk from San Marco, but you can utilize the bus lines that run from the northern border of the neighborhood to cut down that travel time. 

IQ Hotel Firenze: A Great Value in San Marco

I stayed at an IQ Hotel in Milan (and it made my guide to the best places to stay in Milan), and it was an extremely positive experience from start to finish.

Great, helpful staff, comfortable beds, and nice public spaces in the hotel. 

For my upcoming trip to Florence in the spring, I had an extra night in Florence after my family was leaving, and I was looking for somewhere to stay that was convenient to the airport and would be a comfortable place to spend a night solo and I stumbled on the IQ Hotel location in Florence. 

Given my previous experience, I hesitated for approximately fourteen seconds before booking. 

It’s a similar proposition – a hotel in a less prestigious but still convenient location (the hotel in Milan is right near Stazione Centrale) with comfortable rooms for sleeping and nice public spaces to spend your time when you’re not out and about. 

In this particular case, they actually have a public pool. 

The two room types that stand out as unique are the double rooms with a terrace – which have a nice little private outdoor patio added onto a standard double room – and their triple rooms, which would be a good space for a few friends or family members who don’t mind sharing a relatively compact space. 

They also have a third room type that might be interesting for families and groups – a pair of connecting rooms where they share a single entrance and then have two separate interior rooms (kind of like a two bedroom apartment) with two separate bedrooms and bathrooms. 

Needless to say, I will update this section when I actually stay there, but I’m excited about it. 

Room Mate Luca: A Solid Mid-Range Hotel

The second Room Mate hotel on this list, this charming hotel is less luxury, more youthful energy. The rooms are less ornate in their decorations, and a lot more simple (which is certainly not necessarily a bad thing). 

The result is that they’re also more affordable, generally speaking. 

It’s also true the location here is slightly less convenient than their other location, though it is closer to the train station and about the same distance from the Duomo. 

Rooms here come in a couple of configurations – single, double (with options for two twin beds or a double), and triple rooms that are good for small groups traveling together. 

Breakfast is also included in the room rate, which is a nice touch (though we generally prefer to eat somewhere out and about to experience the city rather than at the hotel). 

San Giuliano Inn: An Intimate Guesthouse with Nice Perks

This small guesthouse in San Marco is one floor of a 19th Century building, which is a thing that I have only really encountered in Italy (both in Rome and also in Bologna).

You’ll enter the building and pass lawyers offices and other businesses on your way to the front door of the hotel – it’s a funny experience. 

There are only six rooms here, which means super personal service and 

The first thing you need to know is that they only accept adult guests here, though they recommend nearby Hotel Rapallo for families with kids (which is owned by the same people and has similarly glowing reviews). 

The rooms here come in two types: standard double rooms and slightly bigger rooms with a view of the Duomo, which are going to cost you a little extra. 

A couple of perks of staying here: free breakfast (meaning coffee & cornetti, not a continental breakfast), and free drinks (including some alcoholic options) are included in your rate. 

It’s also worth noting that reception is not 24/7, so check-in is a little more complicated than with a bigger hotel, but that’s going to be a tradeoff that comes with a smaller, more intimate guesthouse.

Santa Maria Novella: A Convenient Area for Short Stays and Day Trips

Generally speaking, the area immediately around a train station in any European city that sees a lot of tourists – which Florence certainly qualifies for – is not going to be the most charming part of the city. 

However, in cities like Madrid, Milan, and Barcelona (and, spoiler alert, Florence!) where there are a lot of great day trips nearby, it can be convenient to stay near the train station to avoid trekking across the city to catch your train to whatever day trips you’re heading out to. 

Alternatively, if you only have one day in Florence on your broader trip to Italy, staying near the train station can be a good way to maximize your time actually exploring (rather than being in transit to and from the train station). 

The area around Florence is home to a wealth of great day trip destinations – Bologna, Lucca, and Siena (to name a few, we have a whole guide dedicated to great day trips from Florence) – and they are all a short train ride away from Florence’s main train station, Santa Maria Novella. 

For the purposes of this particular guide, we’re talking about the area within several blocks of the train station in either direction, but PARTICULARLY the area to the southwest between the eponymous basilica (the Basilica of Santa Maria Novella) and the Arno River. 

Technically, the neighborhood extends far to the west along the river, but to maximize the benefit of being near the train station, we’d stay closer in (look at hotels east of Viale Fratelli Rosselli). 

This is the part of the neighborhood where you’ll get the best balance of centrality (a 5-10 minute walk to the train station) and hotel choice. 

It’s not the sexiest neighborhood in Florence, and it is a bit further from Florence’s main historic center than some of the other neighborhoods we’ve covered, but it would make a convenient home base for a short stay or if you’re using Florence as a home base to do multiple day trips. 

Pros and Cons of Staying in Santa Maria Novella

Here are the pros and cons of staying in Santa Maria Novella as we see them.

Pros of Staying in Santa Maria Novella

• It’s near the train station. Perfect for day trips! We recommend using Florence as a base to do day trips in all of our Italy itineraries (here’s our 10 day Italy itinerary, for reference), and staying near the train station will make this about as easy as it gets.
  
  
• Lots of hotel choices. This neighborhood has tons of hotel options to choose from, particularly in the area we recommend southwest of the train station close to the river. 
  
  
• Budget-friendly options. Since it’s not the most desirable neighborhood in Florence AND there are a lot of hotel options, there’s a nice range of budgets represented here. Generally speaking, the same room is going to be 10-20% cheaper here than in the historic center (if not more). 

Cons of Staying in Santa Maria Novella

• The food and drink options are elsewhere. With few exceptions, you’re going to want to plan on eating your meals elsewhere. The biggest exception is Fuoco Matto, which is on the border with San Marco and was recommended to me by a local (though I can’t eat there because they don’t have safe gluten free options). 
  
  
• It’s far from places like Santa Croce and Oltrarno. While it’s relatively close to the historic center (10-15 minute walk), it’s further from Santa Croce, Sant’Ambrogio, and Oltrarno. And the bus options aren’t great in Florence, so it’s not like you can easily cut down that travel time.

---